Should I rent or should I buy a house in Costa Rica?

Written by Michael Simons on . Posted in Buying and Selling Property in Costa Rica, FAQ's, Investing in Costa Rica, Tres Amigos Realty Group

A very common question I receive when people begin looking at making the move to Costa Rica is, “Should I rent or should I buy a house in Costa Rica“? People make the point that you should rent in Costa Rica for a while, to make sure you like it before you buy. There is obviously some merit to this and of course each person has a different opinion.  Personally, I have always been a firm believer in home ownership as that is the American Dream, right?  

I have owned many properties in my life, buying my first house at 23 years old. I have never wanted to rent a property for quite a few different reasons.  First of all, it isn’t MY property.  So I can’t do what I want.  I can’t paint it the color I like, build the BBQ I need, or plant the landscaping I want to see every day.  I am at the mercy of the owner and must live by their rules.  Now, if the owner happens to be a great guy, who is very flexible, then that might work out ok.  But what if the owner isn’t easy to deal with?  We have all heard the horror stories of crazy landlords and I have never wanted to put myself in that situation.  I have owned every property I have ever lived in, and I also own the real estate that my businesses operate on.


There are also some things you have to remember about Costa Rica. We are not your normal real estate market like you might have in Omaha, Nebraska.  The majority of people who buy a house in Costa Rica are planning to use it themselves.  They have searched the world and picked Costa Rica as their destination.  They toured all over this gorgeous country and found our little paradise here in Playa Hermosa and the Papagayo.  They are planning to use this property as their vacation home or their retirement home.  So the last thing they want to do is rent it out on a long-term full-time basis.

buy a house in Costa Rica like this one

 There are 3 kinds of home and condo buyers of real estate in Costa Rica.  Obviously people who buy lots, with the plan to build in the future, don’t have the ability to rent it out, so we won’t consider these buyers for this particular article.

The first are people who are going to live or retire in Costa Rica.  Even if they are only going to be snow birds, they will spend at least 6 months a year in their home, but many live here full-time year-round, only going back for various holidays and family events.  So obviously they can’t rent it to someone for 12 months.  Besides, if they did rent it to you for the time they were back home, at the end of the 6 months you would have an almost impossible time finding another place to move into.  Then what?

The second type of buyer is someone who will buy a house in Costa Rica as an investment and then try to maximize their return.  If you spend any time on the internet, talking to property managers and rental companies you will quickly find that the rental market is doing GREAT.  Most people who own a condo or a house here have a company that rents it to tourists for short term rentals.  The majority of my clients, who are renting their homes this way, are getting anywhere from 20 to 25 weeks a year of vacation rentals, and sometimes MORE.  This of course depends on the quality of the property and the skill of the manager, and your commitment to making it happen, by spending the money it takes to make the home appealing.  And usually they can get as much for one week to a vacation renter as they can for a month to a long term renter.  

So why would you rent it to someone for 12 months, when you can vacation rent it and make as much if not more. Plus you still have the ability to use it during the vacant weeks and months.  This is the most common buyer’s profile.  They want to be able to use this property anywhere from 4 to 8 weeks a year or more and have the home making them money when they aren’t.  You can’t do that if you have a long term renter in your house.  There are some fantastic vacation rental agencies in town who can give you more information on what you can expect to make on a property.

Jeffry at Milagro Management and Rentals

Tim at Zindis 

David at Rich Coast Vacations Rich Coast Vacations (

Diego at Star Villas Choose a Luxury All Inclusive Vacations Villa in Costa Rica (

Jennifer at Brokers Costa Rica Luxury Rental Homes and Villas – Costa Rica Brokers (

Dean and Sandy

The third buyer is someone who buys a home today, with the plan to move here full-time in the future.  They usually have a 5 year plan of action and have to make a decision on what to do with the home in the meantime.  They are purchasing today because they want to get the absolute best price they can.  If they wait 5 years to buy a house in Costa Rica, many people feel they won’t be able to afford the same quality of home they can get today.  And the majority of these people always say the same thing to me.  “I don’t want someone sleeping in my bed” so they leave the house empty, and just occasionally come down and use it until they are ready to make the jump full-time.  The Majority of these buyers DO NOT rent their homes out at all but instead choose to have a property manager look after the house while they are not there.  But some of these people do occasionally rent their homes long term yet many of them still choose the second option of vacation rentals when they see the potential for income.  But even if they choose to rent this home long term, we tend to have a problem. Here is what it is.

Many of these homes are not your basic rental home.  They are very nice properties, many of them worth substantially more than your average rental property in the USA or Canada.  If someone has $500k invested in a retirement property, they surely aren’t going to rent it to someone for what most renters want to pay.  The average long term renter wants to spend $1000 to $1500 per month or LESS on their home or condo.  Obviously, someone who has spent a big chunk of money on a gorgeous retirement property is not going to allow someone to live in it for this small fee.  So they choose instead to leave the house vacant and just have a property manager look after it for them, especially since the carrying and operating costs on properties here in Costa Rica is relatively small compared to North America or Europe.  There are a couple great property managers who can give you an idea of the costs to maintain an empty home.

Wes and Lisa Rintelen

Chuck Levanchy

 Most renters find out very quickly 3 things:

  1. Most properties are not available for long term rent.
  2. The properties that are available are much more money than they are willing or capable of paying.
  3. They must settle for living in a home way below their standards.

This is what I usually find out happens to most people who come here and rent.  They end up staying in what we would call a Tico home.  It is a very simple home, nothing like you would rent back in your home country.   There is no swimming pool or beautiful yard.  Many times the property doesn’t even have hot water.  There is no dishwasher or dryer and very rarely does it have AC.  The house or condo is usually located in a less desirable location, and this lends itself to other potential problems, such as break-ins and crime.  If they are one of the few lucky ones who do find a suitable North American style home for rent, they have to worry about other potential inconveniences.  The owner or landlord NEVER wants to rent the house for more than a year lease, so people have to almost immediately start trying to figure out where they will live next year.  

Also, the market is definitely coming back and prices are rising.  So you have to worry about the landlord or owner raising the rent substantially on the second year lease or even selling the house out from under you, as the prices here climb back up the ladder.  The biggest hurdle that these people are going to face is that at some point, there will be NO homes for rent long-term.  The 5 year plans will come to fruition, and the owners will all want to retire and move into their properties.  The new expansion of the Liberia airport is bringing more and more people every day to the Papagayo.  So the homes that might be sitting for sale, and available for rent, are being sold and coming off the market.  Inventory is shrinking, as it becomes harder and harder to develop in Costa Rica.  This country makes it incredibly difficult for a developer to take a project from raw land to completion.  So we are not going to see a constant flow of new inventory like you might in other countries.  This of course will create more demand than supply, and inventory will shrink and prices will rise.  Just recently, I have had 3 different clients try to find a long term rental, and every single property manager told them the same thing: “Sorry, we have nothing available.”

South America is also now a direct destination to Liberia airport as COPA airlines bring buyers direct from Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia Venezuela and Panama.  There is a tremendous amount of wealth in South America and we are very excited about seeing that money here in our back yard.  Also, remember, May to September is South America winter, so our slow season will become a second high season, as those people want to get away from the cold and enjoy a nice Costa Rican beach vacation. This will allow year round vacation rentals to flourish, drying up any other long term rental opportunities.

Also, I have found, as you can read in some of my other blogs that probably 95% of the people DO fall in love with Costa Rica and end up wanting to make this their residence.  But by the time these people figure it out, they will pay substantially more for the same house that they could have bought it for today.  So let’s say you find a nice home that you can buy today for $300,000.  If you rent that house for 2 years at $1500 a month you just burned up $36k.  In two years you will probably pay a minimum of 10 to 20% more for this house, as we are just flat out running out of inventory. Which means renting for 2 years just cost you somewhere between $66 and $100k.  I don’t know about you, but that doesn’t seem to make good financial sense to me.  I would rather buy that house now and then if for some reason I decide to return to the USA, sell the property and make that money myself.

The reality is, most people who are telling you to rent before buy, are probably saying that because they just can’t afford to buy a house in Costa Rica.  People, who can afford to purchase homes, ALWAYS buy and never rent. Remember, successful people got wealthy by BUYING at the right time and SELLING at the right time. Don’t wait a couple years to come down here and purchase.  The deals will be gone and you will be kicking yourself for missing out on the opportunity.

 Pura Vida

Michael D Simons
Co Owner/Broker
Office 011-506-2672-4100
Cell    011-506-8812-2242

Tags: , ,

July 2024
« May    

Tres Amigos on Facebook

Tres Amigos on Facebook

Sign up for my Newsletter


Prestige Ocean Properties on Facebook

RE/MAX Prestige Ocean Properties

©2012-2020 All Rights reserved.